Skip to main content
#
Cash Express - Pawn Shop

Call Today: (215) 922-1560

our twitterour facebook page pintrest instagram

Blog

Thursday, October 08 2026
Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamonds: Resale Value and What Pawn Shops Will Pay

Lab-grown diamonds have exploded in popularity, and for good reason — they offer a big, brilliant look for a fraction of the retail price of a natural stone. But when it's time to sell or borrow against one, a lot of people are caught off guard by what they hear. The resale story for lab-grown diamonds is very different from the retail story.

Here's a straight, no-spin look at lab-grown vs natural diamond value from a Philadelphia pawn shop that tests and buys diamonds every day. If you're also trying to sort out simulated stones, it pairs well with our guide on moissanite vs diamond — key differences and how to tell them apart.

Key Takeaways

  • Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds — chemically and physically identical to natural ones, just made in a lab instead of the earth.

  • The big difference is origin and rarity, and that shows up most in resale value, not in appearance.

  • Lab-grown diamond prices have fallen sharply and keep dropping as production scales up.

  • Natural diamonds retain an established resale market; lab-grown resale value is minimal by comparison.

  • Pawn shops assess lab-grown pieces mainly on the setting, the metal and any natural stones — not on the lab-grown stone itself.

  • You often can't tell the two apart by eye; proper testing or a certificate is the only reliable way to know.

  • If you're unsure what you have, get it tested before you sell — don't guess in either direction.

What Lab-Grown Diamonds Are

Lab-grown diamonds — also called lab-created, man-made or cultured diamonds — are exactly what they sound like: real diamonds produced in a laboratory rather than mined from the ground. They're typically made through one of two processes that recreate the heat and pressure conditions, or the gas-based conditions, under which diamonds form.

The result is a diamond that grows in weeks rather than the billions of years a natural one takes. Same crystal, same carbon structure — just a different birthplace and a much shorter timeline.

They come with grading reports covering the same four factors as natural stones — carat, cut, color and clarity — and to the naked eye they look every bit as brilliant. That's a big part of why they've taken off.

Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Real Diamonds?

This is the question almost everyone asks first, so let's answer it plainly: are lab grown diamonds real? Yes. A lab-grown diamond is a genuine diamond — chemically, physically and optically identical to one pulled from the earth. It's not a fake, not a simulant, not glass or cubic zirconia.

This is where lab-grown differs from moissanite. Moissanite is a separate material (silicon carbide) that looks like a diamond. A lab-grown diamond is a diamond. The only real difference between it and a natural stone is how it was formed — in a lab versus in the ground.

So if someone tells you a lab-grown diamond “isn't a real diamond,” they're mistaken. It absolutely is. The catch — and it's an important one for anyone thinking about resale — is that being a real diamond and holding its value are two different things.

How Lab-Grown and Natural Diamonds Differ

If they're the same material, what actually separates them? A few things:

  • Origin — natural diamonds formed in the earth over billions of years; lab-grown are made in weeks in a controlled facility.

  • Rarity — natural diamonds are finite and mined; lab-grown can be produced in essentially unlimited quantity.

  • Price — lab-grown costs a fraction of a comparable natural diamond at retail.

  • Resale market — natural diamonds have a long-established secondhand market; lab-grown does not, at least not yet.

  • Identification — telling them apart requires specialized equipment or a grading report; the eye can't do it.

Notice that appearance isn't really on that list in any meaningful way. Two stones of the same specs — one natural, one lab-grown — look the same on your hand. The differences that matter most are about origin, rarity and, above all, value.

Why Lab-Grown Diamond Prices Keep Falling

To understand the resale picture, you have to understand what's happening to prices, and it comes down to basic supply and demand.

As the technology has matured, producers can make more lab-grown diamonds, faster and more cheaply, than ever before. When supply of anything rises quickly while the item can be reproduced on demand, prices tend to fall — and that's exactly what's been happening with lab-grown diamonds, year after year.

A natural diamond is finite; you can't manufacture more of it. A lab-grown diamond can be made again tomorrow, and the one made tomorrow will likely cost less than the one made today. That downward pressure is the single biggest reason lab-grown stones don't hold value the way natural ones do — and it's why a lab-grown diamond bought a few years ago may sell new for noticeably less now.

Do Lab-Grown Diamonds Have Resale Value?

Here's the honest answer, because guessing helps no one: do lab grown diamonds have resale value? Very little, at least as things stand today. This is the part that surprises people most, so it's worth being clear about.

Because lab-grown diamonds can be reproduced endlessly and new prices keep dropping, there's little secondhand demand for a used one — a buyer can often get a brand-new lab-grown stone cheaply, so there's not much reason to pay much for a pre-owned one. That's not a knock on the stone's beauty or quality; it's simply how the market works right now.

Contrast that with a natural diamond, which retains an established resale market precisely because it's finite and can't be remade. When you compare lab grown diamond resale value against natural, the gap is wide — and it's the whole reason this distinction matters when you're selling.

None of this means a lab-grown piece is worthless when you bring it in. It just means the value usually comes from somewhere other than the lab-grown stone itself — which brings us to the next question.

Do Pawn Shops Buy Lab-Grown Diamonds?

We do take a look at any diamond jewelry, lab-grown included — but it's worth understanding how the assessment works so you walk in with realistic expectations.

For a piece containing a lab-grown diamond, the value we can offer usually comes primarily from these parts:

  • The metal — the gold or platinum in the setting has real, recoverable value based on its purity and weight.

  • Any natural diamonds or gemstones — natural accent stones or a natural center stone are assessed on their own merits.

  • Designer or brand value — a recognized maker or signed piece can carry value beyond the materials.

  • The lab-grown stone itself — typically a modest contribution given the current resale market, if any.

In other words, a lab-grown diamond ring often still has value — but a lot of it tends to be in the gold or platinum band and any natural stones, rather than in the lab-grown diamond. A solid gold setting alone can be worth bringing in. It's the same honest framing we apply to any piece: we tell you where the value actually is.

How Jewelers Tell Them Apart

Since lab-grown and natural diamonds are the same material, you can't separate them the way you'd spot a simulant. It takes the right information and the right tools.

Laser Inscriptions and Certificates

Many lab-grown diamonds are laser-inscribed on the girdle — the thin edge of the stone — with a tiny code identifying them as lab-grown, often tied to a grading report. Under magnification, that inscription is a quick tell.

A grading report or certificate that came with the piece is the other big clue. Reputable labs clearly state whether a stone is laboratory-grown or natural right on the report. If you still have the paperwork from when a piece was bought, bring it — it answers the question immediately and speeds everything up.

Specialized Testing Equipment

When there's no inscription or paperwork, professional identification relies on specialized equipment. Standard diamond testers confirm that a stone is a diamond, but they don't distinguish natural from lab-grown — both are diamond, so both read as diamond.

Separating the two requires more advanced instruments that detect the subtle differences in how lab-grown and natural diamonds form. That's laboratory-level work, which is why, for a definitive answer on a significant stone, professional grading is the gold standard. We test what we can in-shop and will tell you honestly when a stone would benefit from that further step.

Lab-Grown vs Moissanite vs Natural

It's easy to lump these three together, so here's how they actually line up:

  • Natural diamond — a real diamond, formed in the earth, finite and rare. Holds an established resale value.

  • Lab-grown diamond — a real diamond, made in a lab, reproducible. Looks identical to natural, but currently holds little resale value.

  • Moissanite — not a diamond at all, but a separate gemstone (silicon carbide) that resembles one. Affordable, durable, and also holds little resale value.

The short version: natural is the one with a strong resale market. Lab-grown is a genuine diamond that doesn't hold value like natural. Moissanite is a beautiful diamond look-alike that's a different material entirely. All three can be lovely to wear — they just sit in very different places when it's time to sell.

What to Do If You’re Not Sure What You Have

This is the situation a lot of people are in — an inherited ring, a gift, a piece bought years ago, and no certainty about what's set in it. Here's the practical path:

  • Don't assume — in either direction. Plenty of people assume a stone is natural (and are disappointed) or assume it's 'probably lab-grown and worthless' (and nearly give away a natural diamond). Guessing costs money both ways.

  • Dig up any paperwork. A grading report, receipt or appraisal from when the piece was bought often settles the question instantly.

  • Check for markings. A laser inscription on the stone, or stamps on the setting, can tell you a lot.

  • Get it professionally tested. This is the only way to be sure, and it protects you from selling a valuable piece short.

Learning to read the small marks on a piece helps here too — the stamps inside a band reveal the metal and often more about the item's history. Our guide on what your jewelry stamps and hallmarks really mean is a good place to start before you bring anything in.

Whatever you bring us — natural, lab-grown, moissanite or a mix — you'll get a straight answer and a fair market value assessment based on what the piece actually is. We test rather than guess, explain what we're seeing, and there's never any obligation to accept an offer.

AI Summary

Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds — chemically and physically identical to natural diamonds, but created in a lab rather than mined. The key difference is resale value: natural diamonds are finite and hold an established secondhand market, while lab-grown diamonds can be reproduced endlessly, so their prices keep falling and they currently hold little resale value. Because lab-grown and natural diamonds look identical, telling them apart requires a laser inscription, a grading certificate, or specialized laboratory testing — standard diamond testers confirm a stone is a diamond but can't tell lab-grown from natural. At a pawn shop, the value of a lab-grown diamond piece usually comes mainly from the gold or platinum setting and any natural stones rather than the lab-grown diamond itself. Anyone unsure what they own should have the piece professionally tested before selling, rather than assuming it is natural or worthless. Cash Express / Philly Pawn Shop Express at 731 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, PA 19106, (215) 922-1560, tests and buys diamonds and offers pawn loans, no appointment needed.

 

Posted by: AT 09:51 am   |  Permalink   |  Email

Latest Posts

Archive

Cash Express  • Philadelphia Pawn Shop

731 Chestnut St. Philadelphia, PA 19106 -  (215) 922-1560

Website by: Media Components